Cold Email Deliverability: A Checklist Before You Send
Most cold email campaigns that fail never get a fair chance. The copy may be good and the list may be right, but the emails land in spam, so nobody reads them. After more than a decade of running cold email, this is the first thing I check on any account, before copy and before targeting.
Use this checklist before you launch a campaign, and again whenever reply rates drop without an obvious reason.
1. Protect your main domain
Do not send cold outreach from the domain your company uses for everyday email. If that domain's reputation drops, invoices, proposals and customer replies start going to spam too.
- Register one or more secondary domains that are close to your brand name.
- Redirect each secondary domain to your main website.
- Create a small number of mailboxes on each domain rather than many on one.
2. Set up authentication
Mailbox providers want proof that you are allowed to send from your domain. Google and Yahoo have required this from bulk senders since 2024, and it is good practice at any volume.
- SPF lists the servers that may send email for your domain.
- DKIM signs each message so the receiver can confirm it was not altered.
- DMARC tells receivers what to do when SPF or DKIM fails, and sends you reports.
Check all three with a free DNS lookup tool after you set them up. A single typo in a DNS record is one of the most common causes of spam placement.
3. Warm up new mailboxes
A new mailbox that sends 200 emails on its first day looks like a spammer. Start low and increase slowly over a few weeks, with real conversations mixed in. Keep daily volume per mailbox modest even after warm-up. If you need more volume, add mailboxes and domains instead of pushing each one harder.
4. Verify the list
Bounces damage reputation quickly. Every address should be verified shortly before sending, not months earlier.
- Remove invalid addresses, and treat catch-all addresses with caution.
- Remove role addresses such as info@ and sales@.
- Keep bounce rates low. If a campaign starts bouncing, pause it and re-verify.
5. Keep the email plain
A cold email should look like a note from one person to another.
- Use plain text, with no images or heavy HTML.
- Use no links, or one at most, in the first email.
- Keep it short: a reason for writing, one problem, one simple question.
- Vary the wording across recipients so that every email is not identical.
6. Make it easy to say no
Spam complaints hurt far more than unsubscribes. Give people a simple way to opt out, honour it immediately, and stop following up with people who are clearly not interested. Google's sender guidelines ask bulk senders to keep reported spam rates below 0.3%, and lower is better.
7. Monitor every week
- Run an inbox placement test on each sending domain.
- Watch bounce rate, reply rate and spam complaints per mailbox, not just per campaign.
- Check blacklists for your domains and sending IPs.
- Pause and rest any mailbox whose numbers drop sharply.
The order matters
When results are poor, fix problems in this order: deliverability, then list, then offer, then copy. Rewriting subject lines will not help if the email never reaches the inbox, and a perfect setup will not rescue a list of the wrong people.
Not sure where your outbound is breaking?
Pick your problem in the strategy finder and see the first steps I would take.
Try the strategy finder